quik ID help please

This is a discussion on quik ID help please within the New To Reefkeeping forums, part of the And the Journey Begins category; New to saltwater, found this growing on some rock, popped off its stem during water change, now resides on sand bed. Can anyone tell me what this is please...? it grew pretty fast, about the size of silver dollar now. ...

Share
  • The Facebook Platform
  • + Reply to Thread
    Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
    Results 1 to 15 of 22
    1. #1
      Porkchop
      Copepod

      quik ID help please

      New to saltwater, found this growing on some rock, popped off its stem during water change, now resides on sand bed.
      Can anyone tell me what this is please...?
      it grew pretty fast, about the size of silver dollar now. Anyone know how big it might get as well?
      Oh, and will the stem grow another?
      Thanks


    2. #2
      IPisces
      RF Staff
      My first thought is a fungia plate coral but not quite. Does it have a hard skeleton?

      You say it had a stem? Can you get a pic of it?

    3. #3
      Porkchop
      Copepod
      Ok, so it seems to have popped off of this stem looking thing here.
      the coral has a hard skeleton about the size of a dime, underneath and in center.
      the coral it self, is alot of soft tissue, as it shrunk up to quarter size when i checked for skeletal.


    4. #4
      jrgilles
      Sea Urchin
      Nice hitchhiker. No idea what it is though...

    5. #5
      Herefishyfishy
      Smart Bass
      Not sure of species, but if a LPS is healthy as this polyp appears to be and gets enough light and nutrients, will definately grow more skeleton.
      The base doesn't look calcarious though. Is it hard like rock or leathery?

    6. #6
      trido
      Fish Tank Freak
      Definately looks like a fungia in the sand bed to me

    7. #7
      Herefishyfishy
      Smart Bass
      Duane I agree polyp looks like one, but if it polyp came from that base pointed to, kinda rules that out as fungia always have that flat ridged plate skeleton

    8. #8
      Krish
      Gender: Male
      If it is growing nicely, may not be too sensitive to water conditions as I see what appears to be a diatom bloom on the sand bed so probably not a mature system.


      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    9. #9
      1guydude
      Goby
      +1 looks like a new or newer set up.
      Could be a rock nem of some kind... ive got a some.

    10. #10
      Porkchop
      Copepod
      Well... Thanks for the input, but still unknown.
      W/O touching base, it seems leathery, but skeltal bit underside of head seems bony.
      Bu,t didnt disturb/handle it to much, just a quik grope....
      I was just hopin that someone knew by appearance what it could be...
      Thanks all....

    11. #11
      IPisces
      RF Staff
      Well you've got us a little puzzled...But we will keep our eyes out for anything that it could be.

    12. #12
      Herefishyfishy
      Smart Bass
      If there had been no narrative offered, would have guessed they were two distinct animals. The tan one a fragment of a toadstool leather and the item in the sand a baby Fungia. Both creatures readily reproduce by budding/dropping

    13. #13
      BReefed
      Amphipod
      Quote Originally Posted by Porkchop View Post
      ...but skeltal bit underside of head seems bony.
      Sure sounds like a LPS? Applying Occum's Razor here, what prevents it from being a fungia?

      Only thing I would say is that I don't see a ridged skeleton of any kind. If there was one I'd guess F. Scutaria or F. Somervillei.

      Can you take a top down photo?

      Might want to move it away from that frog anyway?

    14. #14
      Porkchop
      Copepod
      Cool, thanks for input, i will look into it
      K well now the stem seems to be producing another head....
      Or am i just wishful thinking?
      I will post a new pic from top soon.
      Head keeps moving in sand. 6-7" over 3-4 day period




    15. #15
      Porkchop
      Copepod
      BReefed, I think you nailed it... F. Scutaria
      i did a google search and this seems to be as close as one could guess
      couple cool videos of time lapse diggin itself out of burial too.
      Video: Buried corals dig themselves out of trouble | News | Practical Fishkeeping
      Thanks

    + Reply to Thread
    Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast